Skip to content
Saturday, November 14, 2026
OpenlyFeeds

Which Players Has Made Troy's Top-Flight Weekly Best XI?

In the wake of every set of English top-flight games during the current campaign, BBC football analyst Troy Deeney selects his XI and manager of the week.

Take a look at the most recent choices. Do you agree? Give us your opinions.

Between the Sticks

Jordan Pickford (Everton): A crucial incident in the Toffees' 3-0 victory against the Blues was his outstanding denial to deny Enzo Fernandez. The goalkeeper has come up pretty big in those situations for his club throughout the campaign and, hopefully, he will carry on for England at the upcoming World Cup. Recently, he committed a expensive mistake against Arsenal but has since bounced back admirably to perform for the Toffees.

The Defenders

Neco Williams (Nottingham Forest): It shaped up as a huge must-win fixture for Forest away at Tottenham, with Premier League status at stake for both sides. And Williams put in a tremendous showing to aid his side claim a critical three points in the battle against the drop. He bagged a pair of assists, coming up with the goods when it mattered most.

Matty Cash (Aston Villa): In my view, West Ham provided a major danger in attack but Cash was solid and held the line for Villa. He was able to just maintaining possession. He offered a lot in an attacking sense and was also able to snuff out anything and everything the Hammers attempted in attack.

James Tarkowski (Everton): It was a further assured outing from the Toffees defender. He exhibited his experience and authority, and consistently where he needed to be. He executed those tackles when required and, crucially, served as a steadying figure in their backline. How Chelsea crave a centre-back with that kind of fortitude, particularly in light of the unconvincing defending they have shown at times.

Central Park

Chris Rigg (Sunderland): It amounted to a solid performance from Rigg in a unforgettable Tyne-Wear derby. He didn't produce anything spectacular against Newcastle but he executed all his duties exceptionally competently. With Rigg, you understand what you are getting from him.

James Garner (Everton): He easily could have just chilled out following his selection to the England squad this week. But instead, he cracked on and produced a superb shift. It was a delightful pass from him to Beto for Everton's opener. Having played with him at Watford, I know he's synonymous with non-stop running and big tackles. He is the complete package and I trust he does well for England to force his way into that World Cup squad.

John McGinn (Aston Villa): He's their captain, leader and key figure. It's amounted to a pair of huge showings in the span of seven days from him. Villa are a good team. But McGinn elevates them to a great one. If they are going to finish in the Champions League places and contend for the Europa League title, they will need him to keep producing at this level.

Harry Wilson (Fulham): He has cultivated a habit of netting important goals and he repeated the trick once more in the latest round. I question how they are going to replace him if he opts to leave. They are not going to invest a huge sum on somebody with what he offers. They need him to put pen to paper on a new contract as he is a massively important component of that Cottagers team.

The Attack

Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United): It appears that the Portuguese playmaker is turning into a permanent fixture in the weekly best XI. You must put him in once again after a further goal, and additionally being involved in the James Hill own goal. How long will United stay average and keep him before he feels it is the right moment to leave the club?

Beto (Everton): This week, we have a pair of strikers who are at opposite points in their career. I have doubts Beto is a long-term answer for Everton's goalscoring woes, but manager David Moyes is getting a tune out of him right now. It is remarkable given how subpar he was in the initial months.

Danny Welbeck (Brighton): He was omitted by the England manager again for the national team, at a point when they require support to skipper Harry Kane. But Welbeck continued to perform for the Seagulls with a brace, to defeat reigning champions Liverpool, and bring his tally to twelve goals for the campaign.

The Tactical Mastermind

David Moyes (Everton): The fixture between Everton and Chelsea was a perfect example of old school against new school. Blues boss Liam Rosenior is attempting to carve his path at the beginning of his coaching career but Moyes devised a flawless tactical plan to claim a convincing result. The Toffees were more adventurous and more powerful in all departments of the game and it was a massive win for them.

Are you in agreement with Troy's choices? Which players would make up your weekly best XI? Share your thoughts.

Written by

Matthew Holt

A tech journalist with over a decade of experience covering AI, cybersecurity, and emerging digital trends across global markets.

OpenlyFeeds

Type to search articles.